VC Legal Fees: Who Pays After Term Sheet?

When it comes to venture capital (VC) investments, understanding the allocation of legal fees post-term sheet is crucial for both startups and investors. This article explores the common practices and negotiation tactics surrounding the payment of legal fees after the term sheet stage in VC deals.

Talk to us
VC Legal Fees: Who Pays After Term Sheet?

Share article

Venture capital (VC) legal fees can be a significant aspect of the cost of raising funds. After a term sheet is signed, the question of who pays the legal fees can arise. Typically, the company receiving the investment pays the legal fees for both parties, including those of the investor. These fees can cover various aspects such as fund formation, ongoing legal expenses, and side letter negotiations. It's essential for both the company and the investor to understand and negotiate these costs upfront to avoid any misunderstandings later on. Legal expenses for startups raising early-stage venture financing can vary based on the nature of the company's business, location, and other factors.

The Term Sheet Recap

A. Quick Review of the Purpose and Components of a Term Sheet

Before delving into post-term sheet considerations, let's briefly revisit the term sheet's role in the VC process. A term sheet is a preliminary agreement outlining the key terms and conditions of a potential investment. It acts as a roadmap, covering elements such as valuation, investment amount, investor rights, and liquidation preferences. The term sheet serves as a foundation for further negotiations and due diligence.

B. Emphasis on the Non-Binding Nature of a Term Sheet

It's crucial to underscore that a term sheet is generally non-binding. While it sets the framework for the deal, it is not a legally binding agreement. This non-binding nature allows both parties to engage in negotiations without the risk of legal obligations. However, it creates a pivotal transition point where the details outlined in the term sheet must be translated into legally enforceable agreements.

C. Transition from Term Sheet to Definitive Legal Agreements

As parties move beyond the term sheet, the focus shifts to converting the agreed-upon terms into definitive legal agreements. This transition involves a comprehensive legal process, including due diligence, document drafting, and negotiation of the final terms. Legal professionals play a crucial role in ensuring that the intentions outlined in the term sheet are accurately reflected in the binding legal documents that follow.

  • Due Diligence: The post-term sheet phase initiates a more thorough due diligence process, where both parties scrutinize each other's legal, financial, and operational aspects. This in-depth examination aims to identify potential risks and verify the information provided during the term sheet negotiations.

  • Document Drafting: Legal experts draft intricate documents such as the shareholder agreement, investment agreement, and other relevant contracts. These documents serve as the legal framework governing the relationship between the startup and the investor.

  • Negotiation: Though the term sheet sets the foundation, the definitive legal agreements require meticulous negotiation. This phase involves addressing any issues discovered during due diligence, resolving discrepancies, and finalizing the specific language to be used in legally binding documents.

This transition is a critical juncture, emphasizing the need for clear communication and alignment between both parties. Understanding the non-binding nature of the term sheet is essential as stakeholders navigate the intricate legal processes that follow, ensuring a smooth progression toward finalizing the investment deal.

Legal Fees in VC Transactions

A. Overview of the Typical Legal Processes in VC Deals

The legal processes in venture capital transactions are multifaceted, encompassing various stages to ensure a comprehensive and legally sound investment. These processes include:

  • Due Diligence: Thorough examination of the startup's legal, financial, and operational aspects to identify potential risks and ensure accurate representations.

  • Document Drafting: Creation and review of legal documents such as shareholder agreements, investment agreements, and other contracts that govern the terms and conditions of the investment.

  • Regulatory Compliance: Navigating complex regulatory frameworks to ensure that the investment adheres to applicable laws, including securities regulations and intellectual property laws.

  • Negotiation: Discussions and negotiations between parties to address any issues arising during due diligence, resolve discrepancies, and finalize the specific language used in legally binding agreements.

B. Identification of Legal Professionals Involved (Lawyers, Due Diligence Experts)

Various legal professionals play key roles in facilitating VC transactions:

  • Lawyers: Attorneys specializing in venture capital law guide parties through the legal intricacies of the deal. They draft, review, and negotiate legal documents, ensuring compliance with relevant laws and regulations.

  • Due Diligence Experts: Professionals with expertise in due diligence scrutinize the startup's legal, financial, and operational aspects. They provide insights to investors about potential risks and help ensure that information provided during negotiations is accurate.

  • Specialized Counsel: Depending on the nature of the startup and the industry, specialized legal counsel may be involved. This can include intellectual property lawyers, regulatory compliance experts, and industry-specific legal advisors.

C. Discussion on the Significance of Legal Fees in Safeguarding Interests

Legal fees are a crucial component of VC transactions, serving several key purposes:

  • Risk Mitigation: Legal professionals help identify and mitigate risks during due diligence, protecting the interests of both the startup and the investor.

  • Clarity and Compliance: Legal fees ensure that all documents drafted and negotiated comply with relevant laws and regulations, providing a clear and legally binding framework for the investment.

  • Negotiation Expertise: Skilled lawyers play a pivotal role in negotiations, helping parties reach mutually beneficial agreements and resolve any issues that may arise.

  • Long-Term Protection: Investing in robust legal processes and professionals safeguards the long-term interests of both parties, reducing the likelihood of future disputes and legal challenges.

Understanding the significance of legal fees in safeguarding interests reinforces the importance of allocating resources to ensure a thorough and legally sound venture capital transaction. As stakeholders progress through the legal processes, these fees become an investment in the stability and success of the partnership between the startup and the investor.

Responsibilities During the Term Sheet Phase

A. Clarification of the Parties Responsible for Legal Fees Pre-Term Sheet

Before the term sheet is finalized, it's crucial to establish clarity regarding which party or parties will bear the legal fees incurred during the pre-term sheet phase. Typically, each party is responsible for its own legal expenses. However, negotiations may arise regarding certain shared costs, especially in cases where due diligence is extensive.

B. Negotiation Points Related to Legal Expenses in the Term Sheet

The term sheet negotiation phase offers an opportunity for parties to discuss and establish the parameters for legal fees. Key negotiation points include:

  • Fee Structure: Determining the structure of legal fees, whether it be hourly rates, flat fees, or a combination, should be clearly outlined in the term sheet.

  • Caps and Limits: Defining caps or limits on legal fees ensures that both parties have a reasonable expectation of the maximum amount they might incur during the pre-term sheet phase.

  • Shared Expenses: Negotiating shared expenses for certain aspects of due diligence or regulatory compliance can be part of the discussion. This may include splitting the costs of specific third-party experts or reports.

  • Timing of Payments: Addressing when legal fees are to be paid is essential. Parties may agree on payment milestones tied to specific stages of the negotiation process.

C. Common Practices and Industry Standards

While negotiation terms can vary, there are common practices and industry standards observed during the term sheet phase:

  • Each Party Bears Its Own Costs: It's customary for each party to cover its own legal fees during the term sheet phase. This principle aligns with the non-binding nature of the term sheet.

  • Exceptions for Extensive Due Diligence: In cases where due diligence is exceptionally comprehensive, parties may agree to share certain costs. This is often negotiated based on the scope and depth of the investigation.

  • Understanding Industry Norms: Being aware of industry norms regarding legal fees during the term sheet phase is crucial. This understanding can help parties navigate negotiations more effectively and ensure that expectations align with prevailing standards.

  • Flexibility for Unique Circumstances: The term sheet is a flexible document, and parties can customize provisions based on the unique circumstances of the deal. Flexibility allows for adjustments to legal fee arrangements that make sense for both parties.

Negotiating legal expenses during the term sheet phase sets the tone for the collaborative efforts that follow. By addressing these aspects upfront, parties can establish a fair and transparent framework for managing legal fees during the critical pre-term sheet stage.

Unpacking Post-Term Sheet Legal Fees

A. Understanding the Shift in Responsibility After Term Sheet Agreement

The signing of the term sheet marks a pivotal shift in the dynamics of legal responsibilities. While the pre-term sheet phase usually sees each party covering its own legal expenses, post-term sheet, the focus shifts towards finalizing legally binding agreements. The responsibility for legal fees during this phase is typically borne by the startup.

B. Analysis of Which Party Typically Covers Legal Fees in Different Scenarios

  1. Startup Responsibility:

    • Document Drafting: The startup is generally responsible for legal fees associated with drafting and reviewing documents such as the shareholder agreement, investment agreement, and other relevant contracts.
    • Due Diligence: The costs incurred during extensive due diligence processes, including legal due diligence, are typically the responsibility of the startup.
  2. Investor Responsibility:

    • Specialized Counsel: In certain scenarios, investors might engage specialized legal counsel for specific aspects of due diligence or regulatory compliance, and they would bear these associated costs.

It's important to note that while the startup often bears the brunt of legal fees post-term sheet, negotiation and flexibility are key components in determining the specifics of cost-sharing arrangements.

C. Exploration of Potential Negotiation Strategies for Allocating Post-Term Sheet Legal Costs

  1. Fee Caps and Limits:

    • Proposal: Introduce caps or limits on legal fees to provide both parties with a clear understanding of the maximum financial commitment.
    • Negotiation: Discuss and agree upon reasonable caps that align with the complexity and scope of the legal processes involved.
  2. Shared Expenses:

    • Proposal: Propose shared expenses for certain aspects of the legal process, especially if there are unique circumstances or if the due diligence process is unusually extensive.
    • Negotiation: Clearly define the scope of shared expenses and ensure a fair distribution that reflects the mutual benefits derived from the shared processes.
  3. Alternative Fee Structures:

    • Proposal: Explore alternative fee structures, such as fixed fees or blended rates, to provide predictability in legal costs.
    • Negotiation: Discuss the feasibility of alternative fee arrangements and find a mutually agreeable structure that aligns with the financial capacities of both parties.
  4. Transparent Communication:

    • Proposal: Emphasize transparent communication regarding legal expenses to avoid misunderstandings.
    • Negotiation: Establish a collaborative approach by openly discussing the budget, potential cost-sharing scenarios, and any circumstances that may impact legal fees.

Navigating post-term sheet legal fees requires a balance between safeguarding the interests of both the startup and the investor. Negotiation strategies should prioritize fairness, transparency, and a shared understanding of the financial commitments involved in finalizing the venture capital deal.

Factors Influencing Legal Fee Responsibility

A. Complexity and Scale of the Deal

The complexity and scale of a venture capital deal significantly influence the distribution of legal fee responsibilities. In more intricate transactions involving multiple rounds of funding, intricate terms, or cross-border considerations, legal fees tend to escalate. In such cases:

  • Proposal: Acknowledge the complexity and scale in the term sheet negotiations.
  • Negotiation: Discuss a fair allocation of legal fees based on the specific demands of the deal. Parties may consider sharing costs for certain complex components or agreeing to a proportional distribution.

B. Investor Preferences and Market Norms

Investor preferences and prevalent market norms play a crucial role in shaping legal fee responsibilities. Investors may have established practices regarding the allocation of legal costs, and these preferences can be influenced by:

  • Proposal: Research prevailing market norms and investor preferences.
  • Negotiation: Align with market standards where possible, or propose mutually acceptable deviations based on the unique aspects of the deal. Open dialogue with investors about their expectations regarding legal fee responsibilities.

C. Bargaining Power and Leverage Dynamics

The bargaining power and leverage dynamics between the startup and the investor can impact the negotiation of legal fees. In situations where the startup holds stronger bargaining power:

  • Proposal: Leverage negotiation strength to secure favorable terms.
  • Negotiation: Put forth proposals that consider the startup's financial constraints while ensuring fairness. Investors may be more open to sharing certain costs in exchange for other favorable deal terms.

Conversely, if the investor holds stronger leverage:

  • Proposal: Acknowledge investor leverage while seeking equitable terms.
  • Negotiation: Emphasize the value proposition of the startup and, when necessary, express the need for reasonable cost-sharing arrangements that align with industry practices.

Understanding these factors allows both parties to approach legal fee negotiations with a realistic and collaborative mindset. Flexibility and a willingness to adapt to the specific circumstances of the deal can lead to a more amicable resolution that benefits all stakeholders involved in the venture capital transaction.

You may also be interested in: Tech Funds Leverage Private Equity Structures to Accelerate

Get A Demo and experience Zive in action with a complimentary, no-obligation session tailored to your business needs.

Related articles

Change the way you manage funds